I will begin my blog with a Mike Brady (from the Brady Bunch) quote. "I couldn't have said it better myself, but I'll try". Nice posts Matt and Julie.
I know one thing for sure after working in the world of shelters, residential environments, and foster-care, we are a product of our environment. Our life experiences make us who we are, that's for sure. I have worked with children who have witnessed their parents murdered over a bad drug deal, experienced domestic violence in the home in which a parent has ended up dead, and hundreds and hundreds of children that have been exposed to porn and inapprorpriate sexual molestation. I can't help to think that without careful supervision and a structued safe environment, that these children who have been exposed to these violent and traumatic experiences will conduct themselves in the same manner in which they have been exposed.
There isn't much, if anything, that I haven't heard or seen amongst the children that I have worked with. Yet, this video sickens me still. Does anyone else wonder what happens to these kids later in life? Be it a very short experience to kicking, punching, hitting and the simulation of killing, I can't help to wonder what happened to these poor children that were subjected in this video when they grew up.
On that note. We as affective educators have to learn how to deal with these types of children, because it does exhist and it is very real. I have seen many classrooms in which aggressive students have executed a non-productive day for both the teacher and the other students. I have seen good teachers handle situations in which aggressive children have tipped over desks, broken windows, and hurt someone in the process. Even good teachers have a difficult time dealking with de-escalating and proactive measures to stop violent behaviors. I've also come to the understanding that as educators, that's not our fault, but we still must teach and set good examples for our children in hopes that they understand that there are alternatives to violent outbursts. We can not overall change the external enviornment in which our children live in, but we must instill a positive and safe environment for our students. How do we do that?
Has anyone ever heard of a man named Rick Lavoie? He is a distinguished writer and has done several videos on diffuclt children. I tend to worship his views and thoughts on how to manage and deal with challenging children. His thoughts and views are complex, but very simple. He sites a top twenty list for parents. The list suggest twenty basic principles that parents should avoid in order to present positive role models to their chld. Number four on his list is treating others with respect (Lavoie, 2005). Very simple, but means so many things. It was also stated in the book Nice Is Not Enough, were the author states that if we respect our children, then they will respect us (Nucci, 2009). I feel like this is the key to either the success or demise of our children. We must respect our students and therefore we can start a bridge to shaping and changing behavior for affective education in our classrooms.
I truly believe that as affective educators, our job is simple. We must teach first, and secondly and just as important, keep our kids safe in the school system. I submit to you all that negative reiforcement for aggressive behaviors is not the way to change behavior, but positive reinforecment is the only way to gain the desired affects in which we deem appropriate in our schools.
Unfortunately, and sorry for Bobo, but too many people in counseling positions don't have the time to help deal with home environments and the problems that exhist in the home. I submit to you that we need to make the time to build relationships with parents and our students to help maintain safe schools. In hopes, even adults can learn from adults and with our help, our parents understand that fists, guns, knives and other detrimental behaviors are not appropriate ways of showing our children how to grow up.
Final Exit Ticket
Congratulations! You have completed your course on Affective Education. How quickly the time has passed. Each week there was something new to read, process, analyze and evaluate. Believe it or not, I was learning right along with you. How could I not? Considering that many of you provided such rich professional insight. I am a firm believer that it is always good to look at material, theories, and educational frameworks from different perspectives. For that, I thank you. Nonetheless, every course has its highlights; those moments whereby things simply stand-out and make a lot of sense, which leads to our final exit ticket. Please answer the following questions, what was the “ah ha moment for you”? And as a result, what new knowledge have you constructed through our eight week dialogue on Affective Education that strengthened your confidence about teaching moral education?
Video Link to the Bobo Doll Experiment
Review the video depicting Albert Bandura's Bobo Doll Experiment, which looks at aggression, observational and imitative learning. Share your opinion on how or why this experiment fits (or does not fit) into a discussion about affective education. Be sure to support your opinion. This counts as exit tickets for weeks 5 & 6. I look forward to reading your posts.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdh7MngntnI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdh7MngntnI
The Stages of Moral Development
It has been noted that the Domain Theory was established in an attempt to "categorize behaviors into either a moral or social domain"(Freday, 2009), however prior classification systems, such as Kohlberg's theory of moral development, placed morality and social convention in the same developmental domain. Domain theory separates the two and goes on to highlight the differences in a child's development of each (Freday, 2009, para. 2). Do you agree or disagree? Post your views.
With that noted, click on the You Tube link provided. View the Kohlberg video that explores the stages of moral development and post your views and reations to the video in no less than a 100 words. You may use the book or any other reading from class to support your views. Just be inclined to cite your sources. I look forward to reading your post.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zY4etXWYS84
With that noted, click on the You Tube link provided. View the Kohlberg video that explores the stages of moral development and post your views and reations to the video in no less than a 100 words. You may use the book or any other reading from class to support your views. Just be inclined to cite your sources. I look forward to reading your post.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zY4etXWYS84
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Smitty, I think you're dead-on with your opinion that counselors don't have the time needed to address violence that can occur outside school boundaries. As Matt pointed out prior, so much of the aggression is learned behavior from a home-based source and children emulate that with fellow classmates at school. On a different note, I am in awe at the level of experience you have had in your dealings with students in various stressful situations. I'm glad those children had you to rely on for support and guidance. That being said, your commentary and perspective, to me, was rich in insight and wisdom. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteSmitty, I second Julie's comments in addition, you raised a very real point, which is in the act of exposing how children may mimic aggressive behavior that they have been exposed too, the subjects of the video may have been accidently hurt. I don't know what happened to those children. Sadly, I didn't even think to wonder. We assume so much and place a lot of faith in scientist and their theories. I am prayful that some kind of extended debriefing and/or follow-up occured. I know in order to work with human subjects one has be pass a pretty extensive approval process. Your post was good food for thought. Thanks:)
ReplyDeleteI agree with you 100%, Smitty, that we need to take the time as school counselors to truly build relationships with students and their families. My school counselor in high school was unbelievably indifferent to everyone and everything. It was quite stunning. She was definitely not a source of encouragement.
ReplyDeleteWow. Smitty you're making me second guess everything I wrote in my post. You raise some excellent points about the kids in the study and what will happen to them from here on as well as the real-life implications for kids that see these things happening, not to a doll, but to real people that they care about. Whereas I focus more on the validity of the experiment, you have definitely given me some food for thought.
ReplyDeleteSmitty-I liked how you said that we as professionals in the field of mental health and education need to set a good example. It made me realize that sometimes we are their ONLY good example. Having some form of order and predictability in their lives is important. Also, I actually just saw one of Rick LaVoie's videos today at a workshop. Amazing! I strongly recommend others view it as well. He makes so much sense and everything he says seems so simple, yet we make it so challenging for ourselves. I plan on viewing more of his tapes. Thanks for your input!
ReplyDelete